Cosmos Cosmos Hub 2

Are Validators Charging 0% Commission Harmful to the Success of the Cosmos Hub?

Passed
Proposal passes.
YES
59.03%
62.973M ATOM
ABSTAIN
33.28%
35.498M ATOM
NO
7.69%
8.204M ATOM
NO (VETO)
0.01%
5,526.14 ATOM
PROPOSAL DESCRIPTION

This governance proposal is intended to act purely as a signalling proposal. Throughout this history of the Cosmos Hub, there has been much debate about the impact that validators charging 0% commission has on the Cosmos Hub, particularly with respect to the decentralization of the Cosmos Hub and the sustainability for validator operations.

Discussion around this topic has taken place in many places including numerous threads on the Cosmos Forum, public Telegram channels, and in-person meetups. Because this has been one of the primary discussion points in off-chain Cosmos governance discussions, we believe it is important to get a signal on the matter from the on-chain governance process of the Cosmos Hub.

There have been past discussions on the Cosmos Forum about placing an in-protocol restriction on validators from charging 0% commission. forum.cosmos.network

This proposal is NOT proposing a protocol-enforced minimum. It is merely a signalling proposal to query the viewpoint of the bonded Atom holders as a whole.

We encourage people to discuss the question behind this governance proposal in the associated Cosmos Hub forum post here: forum.cosmos.network

Also, for voters who believe that 0% commission rates are harmful to the network, we encourage optionally sharing your belief on what a healthy minimum commission rate for the network using the memo field of their vote transaction on this governance proposal or linking to a longer written explanation such as a Forum or blog post.

The question on this proposal is “Are validators charging 0% commission harmful to the success of the Cosmos Hub?”. A Yes vote is stating that they ARE harmful to the network's success, and a No vote is a statement that they are NOT harmful.

VOTES
Abstain SparkPool
Yes cosmos1krfmhqvfzmxex5uw5atjwfs9xpqel6hvqajkyt
Yes cosmos1d9cfu9staul0ykt6w4eswjdunlv0tlg7cu8t3l
Yes cosmos19swq3un9wsjw3rnghasa9kssp6s3xpr97dsgcq
Yes cosmos1rygf6l3swgyuy9apuuspwleqj4g0sq26fn8kf7
Yes stake.zone
Yes cephalopod equipment coop
Abstain Castlenode
Yes commercio.network
No cosmos1akhswynqs07zj5p2k25r6s4ur45qyjnr30wt59
Abstain Certus One
Yes Sentinel
Yes Umbrella ☔
Abstain IRISnet-Bianjie
Yes Stake Capital
Abstain Staking Fund: the Never Jailed Crew
Yes cosmos18nvt8gzhqwasgfw6dct5ytze7nva9l94x99m56
Yes cosmos1md5dr8cyyl3d6tz824zph5kg7a5dexhgul48mj
Abstain Sikka
Yes melea
Yes Firmamint
Yes cosmos1tl8q0facf2fl3leenh6pc0uvjyqdwcdhus7uyk
Yes cosmos1049ye8lese3s2a6rr2quh3des6pynmqp99zwqa
Yes HyperBlocksPro
No Bity.com
veto cosmos106u7c8d8q5alghrjv4tx4g58ux6pwgcqdds49u
Yes nylira.net
No cosmos1gwjgwpk2lt60puzc9qutd4yqdtwjlk03cxrday
Yes Chorus One
Yes Cosmonaut Consortium 👩🏼‍🚀👨🏿‍🚀
Yes P2P.ORG - P2P Validator
Yes chainflow-cosmos-prodval-01
Yes Everstake
Yes Cosmostation
Abstain StakeWith.Us
Abstain cosmos1qht2a277khy9caeasclmaj42dumpp48wtpnnmq
Yes ATEAM
Yes Ping
No cosmos1laqefwck8mkxt44jfn7fnpynfv9f2utyw55shy
Yes jackzampolin
Yes cosmos17pz7rlzlgsne9luslvxpchn5m3p5fgrqefg08x
Yes Simply VC
Abstain DappPub
Abstain NewRoad.Capital
Yes Dominator
Yes SecThor42 | Vali the Thor
Yes KalpaTech
Yes Staking Facilities
Yes DragonStake
Yes Easy 2 Stake
Yes WeStaking
Yes Compass
Yes cosmos1unpwkrp2mzv2j4d8x48v5vk4wcpju3es8lax38
Yes iqlusion
Yes cosmos1kjhdx3nkh6krdhryvjzkq33xwh6wsyy785fsga
Yes cosmos1a6kfadt24cgm9fy8z564jrglc27vtfz9kuphjf
No cosmos105l5r3rjtynn7lg362r2m9hkpfvmgmjt7nvq9h
Yes cosmos1e9jlmhjnhv0z5wj64gz0dwn6q523xyxexne9dq
Yes atom.bi23.com
Yes syncnode
No cosmos1qxh5gy9p0c56xe8ep3eg8kd8y39ksmd90cru6y
Yes 🌐 KysenPool.io
Yes ColmenaSvQ🐝
Yes cosmos1mrkn3uug9dm32hyp9tcxs5dmmuspt7nezrdmhz
No Ztake.org
Yes Cosmos-Validator.com
Yes Delega Networks♾
Yes validator.network | Security first. Highly available.
Yes kochacolaj
Abstain cosmos12ealu07v9647r2gjv2u93hk2h2vvcwj9wh7wfk
Yes cosmos1j26c4k2jj9tv95whdhva3e8v2fcm4s3dpt77r6
Yes IØN
Yes cosmos1wgn9vgmpkfutzh60f9d7glwu55x0vhgr5d02ze
No cosmos1068jfs4mhwwtscyxzcgcgugs2qqfm453pcswjz
Yes POS Bakerz
No cosmos1c3ynnn0ra95ehaakss2ultxf7tsw79j9yh8e3d
No cosmos1qc60ztmn89hzn9w8zxd77m7lcpygcjdczkrd6n
No cosmos14xgdfdnpjtulj6p7rkc75ekxqjq8hc5c7x6hpd
Yes cosmos1lugpap3vtd7ncg8hf4zkreqtecgfv5a0kgeeux
No cosmos15njsc4lap2h94xum2xatf9xmex4088u9jcmpv9
Yes 2nd only to Certus One in GoS: in3s.com
Yes cosmos1tcdwhny64sqdcyyhm2ul9fxu4qfhvfntx2a9xk
No cosmos1udndj2rfyzf3fmxucphn354p8cl6nsyhmemchd
No cosmos1t2dwdx4wdv544swwa2n2gtzu3flr47j4ym3ydu
No Forbole
Yes kytzu
veto cosmos1ujg79smadf700xpwdxhm0mv3vy6xgttgmvy6ky
Yes B-Harvest
Info #12
2019-07-23 at 00:28 UTC
60%
107M of 177M ATOM have voted.
Tallying Procedure
40%
50%
33.4%
0.0